By clicking "Accept", you agree to have cookies stored on your device to improve site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist with our marketing efforts. See our privacy policy for more information.
How-to

Strategies for balancing your training dataset

Written by
Nicolas
Published on
2024-10-26
Reading time
This is some text inside of a div block.
min
πŸ“˜ CONTENTS
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

In machine learning, the balance of training datasets is really important for optimizing model performance. If the data is unbalanced, this can lead to biases and limit generalization, compromising the reliability of predictions. To obtain accurate, unbiased results, it is advisable to implement effective strategies for balancing the data used to train the models.

‍

πŸ€” Why is this important? In fact, when the data is unbalanced, the artificial intelligence model tends to favor the majority classes, which can skew the results and lead to inaccurate predictions for the minority classes. This can have serious consequences, particularly in critical fields such as healthcare or finance, where decisions need to be made fairly, accurately and ethically.

‍

Ensuring a good balance in datasets enables models to be trained to treat all classes equally, thus guaranteeing more reliable and unbiased predictions.

‍

‍

πŸ’‘ This article explores key techniques for balancing training datasets. We'll look at why it's important to have balanced data, common resampling methods, and approaches to generating synthetic data. We'll also cover how to evaluate and adjust data balance to optimize model performance. These strategies will help you improve the quality of your training sets and achieve more robust models over the long term!

‍

‍

Understanding the importance of data balance

‍

Definition of a balanced dataset

A balanced dataset refers to a set where classes or categories are represented in approximately equal proportions. In the context of machine learning, this balance is particularly important for classification tasks. An equivalent number of samples for each class ensures that the model does not develop a bias towards any particular class. This balance contributes to more accurate and reliable predictions, particularly in scenarios where the costs of misclassification are high.

‍

On the other hand, an unbalanced dataset occurs when one class is significantly over-represented compared to the others. This imbalance can lead to a biased model that favors the prediction of the majority class, as the model learns to minimize the overall error by favoring the class with the most examples.

‍

‍

An illustration of an unbalanced and balanced dataset (source: Minasha Saini, Seba Susan)

‍

‍

‍

Impact on model performance

Data balance has a considerable influence on the performance of machine learning models. A balanced dataset ensures that the model has enough examples of each class to learn from, leading to better generalization and more accurate predictions. This is particularly important in areas such as fraud detection, medical diagnostics and customer segmentation, where misclassification can lead to significant financial losses, health risks or missed opportunities.

‍

In addition, a balanced dataset contributes to fairness and ethical practices in AI. For example, in scenarios where data represents different demographic groups, an unbalanced dataset could lead to biased predictions that disproportionately affect under-represented groups. Ensuring data balance thus helps mitigate this risk, leading to fairer outcomes and helping companies comply with regulatory requirements related to discrimination and fairness in the use of artificial intelligence.

‍

Consequences of data imbalance

Data imbalance can have significant consequences for the performance and reliability of machine learning models. We have grouped together some of the main consequences below:

‍

1. Model biases

Unbalanced data can lead to model bias, where the model becomes excessively influenced by the majority class. It may then have difficulty making accurate predictions for the minority class.

‍

‍

An example of the bias of an artificial intelligence algorithm... which obviously didn't recognize Obama. Your models are biased because your data is biased... because it's probably unbalanced! (Source: @hardmaru on X)

‍

‍

2. High precision, low performance

A model trained on unbalanced data may appear to have high accuracy, but may actually perform poorly on minority classes, which are often those of greatest interest.

‍

3. Loss ofinsights‍

Data imbalance can lead to the loss of important information and motives in the minority class, leading to missed opportunities or critical errors.

‍

4. Limited generalization

Models trained on unbalanced datasets may have difficulty generalizing to new, unseen data, especially for the minority class.

‍

‍

🦺 To mitigate these problems, various techniques have been developed, such as resampling,adjusting class weights andusing specialized evaluation metrics that better reflect performance on unbalanced data.

‍

‍

Resampling techniques

‍

To deal with data imbalance problems, the resampling is a widely adopted approach to dataset processing. This technique modifies the composition of the training dataset to obtain a more balanced distribution between classes. Resampling methods fall into two main categories: oversampling and undersampling. We'll explain what they are below!

‍

Oversampling

Oversampling involves adding examples to the minority class to balance the class distribution. This technique is particularly useful when the dataset is small and samples from the minority class are limited.

‍

A simple method of oversampling is the random duplication of examples from the minority class. Although easy to implement, this approach can lead to overlearningas it does not generate any new information.

‍

A more sophisticated technique is the Synthetic Minority Over-sampling Technique (or SMOTE). SMOTE creates new synthetic examples by interpolating between existing instances of the minority class. This method generates artificial data points based on the characteristics of existing samples, thus adding diversity to the training dataset.

‍

Subsampling

Subsampling aims to reduce the number of examples in the majority class to balance the class distribution. This approach can be effective when the dataset is large and the majority class contains many redundant or similar samples.

‍

A simple method of sub-sampling is to randomly remove examples from the majority class. Although this technique can be effective, there is a risk of deleting important information.

‍

More advanced methods, such as Tomek linkslinks, identify and remove pairs of examples that are very close but belong to different classes. This approach increases the space between classes and facilitates the classification process.

‍

Hybrid techniques

Hybrid techniques combine oversampling and undersampling to achieve better results. For example, the SMOTEENN method first applies SMOTE to generate synthetic examples of the minority class, then uses the Edited Nearest Neighbors (ENN) algorithm to clean up the space resulting from oversampling.

‍

Another hybrid approach is SMOTE-Tomek, which applies SMOTE followed by Tomek link removal. This combination results in a cleaner, more balanced feature space.

‍

It's important to note that the choice of resampling technique depends on the specifics of the dataset and the problem to be solved. A thorough evaluation of different methods is often necessary to determine the most appropriate approach for a particular use case.

‍

Synthetic data generation methods

The generation of synthetic data has become an essential tool for improving the quality and diversity of training datasets. These methods create artificial samples that mimic the characteristics of real data, helping to solve class imbalance problems and increase dataset size.

‍

SMOTE(Synthetic Minority Over-sampling Technique)

SMOTE is a popular technique for dealing with unbalanced datasets. It works by creating new synthetic examples for the minority class. The algorithm identifies the k nearest neighbors of a sample of the minority class and generates new points along the lines that connect the sample to its neighbors. This approach makes it possible to increase the representation of the minority class without simply duplicating existing examples, which could lead to overlearning.

‍

Data enhancement

Data augmentation is a widely used technique, particularly in the field of computer vision. It involves applying transformations to existing data to create new variations. For images, these transformations can include rotations, resizing, changes in brightness or the addition of noise. In natural language processing, augmentation can involve synonym substitution or paraphrasing. These techniques expose the model to a wider variety of scenarios, improving its ability to generalize.

‍

Adverse generators(GANs)

Generative adversarial networks (GANs) represent a more advanced approach to synthetic data generation. A GAN consists of two competing neural networks: a generator that creates new data, and a discriminator that attempts to distinguish real data from generated data. As training progresses, the generator improves to produce increasingly realistic data, while the discriminator refines its ability to detect fakes.

‍

GANs have shown promising results in generating synthetic data for various applications, notably in the medical field where they can be used to generate synthetic medical images. These images can help augment limited datasets, thereby improving the performance of classification and segmentation models.

‍

In conclusion, these synthetic data generation methods offer powerful solutions for enriching training datasets. Not only do they help to balance under-represented classes, but they also increase the diversity of the data, thus contributing to improving the robustness and generalizability of machine learning models.

‍

Balance assessment and adjustment

Evaluating and adjusting the equilibrium of the training dataset are critical steps in guaranteeing the optimal performance of machine learning models. This phase involves the use of specific metrics, the application of stratified cross-validation techniques and the iterative adjustment of the dataset.

‍

Metrics for measuring balance

To effectively assess the balance of a dataset, it is essential to use appropriate metrics. Traditional metrics such as overall accuracy can be misleading in the case of unbalanced data. It is preferable to focus on metrics that offer a more comprehensive view of model performance, such as :

- Accuracy : measures the proportion of correct positive predictions among all positive predictions.

- Recall (or sensitivity): evaluates the proportion of true positives among all true positive samples.

- F1 score : represents the harmonic mean of precision and recall, providing a balanced measure of model performance.

‍

In addition, the use of the ROC(Receiver Operating Characteristic) curve and the Precision-Recall curve enables model performance to be visualized at different classification thresholds. These curves help to understand the trade-off between the rate of true positives and the rate of false positives (ROC curve), or between precision and recall (Precision-Recall curve).

‍

‍

Stratified cross-validation

Stratified cross-validation is an advanced technique particularly useful for datasets with an unbalanced class distribution. Unlike standard cross-validation, which randomly divides the dataset, stratified cross-validation ensures that each fold contains approximately the same percentage of samples of each class as the complete set.

‍

This approach ensures a fairer and more reliable evaluation of the model, particularly when certain classes are under-represented. It ensures that the model is trained and evaluated on a representative sample of each class, thus mitigating potential biases and improving the estimation of overall model performance.

‍

Iterative adjustment of the data set

Iterative dataset adjustment is an approach that aims to gradually improve the balance and quality of the training data. This method involves several steps:

‍

1. Initial assessment

Use the appropriate metrics to assess the current balance of the dataset.

‍

2. Problem identification

Analyze results to detect under-represented classes or potential biases.

‍

3. Application of resampling techniques

Use methods such as oversampling or undersampling to adjust the class distribution.

‍

4. Synthetic data generation

If necessary, create new examples for minority classes using techniques such as SMOTE.

‍

5. Revaluation

Re-measure dataset equilibrium after adjustments.

‍

6. Iteration

Repeat the process until a satisfactory balance is achieved.

‍

‍

🧾 It is important to note that iterative fitting must be carried out with care to avoid overlearning. It is recommended to apply cross-validation prior to data resampling to ensure an unbiased assessment of model performance.

‍

‍

‍

‍

Logo


What if we could help you create balanced datasets "by design"?
Don't wait any longer, our team of Data Labelers specialized in Computer Vision can help you build balanced datasets, according to your instructions! We look forward to hearing from you.

‍

‍

‍

Conclusion

‍

Balancing training datasets has a considerable impact on the performance and reliability of machine learning models. Techniques such as resampling, synthetic data generation and iterative fitting offer effective solutions to class imbalance problems. By implementing these strategies, data professionals can improve the quality of their training sets and obtain more robust, unbiased models.

‍

Ultimately, data balancing is not a one-off task, but an ongoing process that requires constant evaluation and adjustment. By using the right metrics and applying stratified cross-validation, teams can ensure that their models perform optimally across all classes. This approach not only improves model performance, but also contributes to more ethical and fair AI practices!

‍

‍

Frequently asked questions

To rebalance an unbalanced dataset, it is possible to use subsampling and oversampling of the majority class. Subsampling involves using a reduced number of examples of the majority class during training.
Data imbalance refers to the unequal distribution of samples between different classes in supervised machine learning and deep learning. This phenomenon can lead to biases in model results, affecting their reliability and efficiency, particularly in critical fields such as healthcare.
To deal with class imbalance in a dataset, we can use techniques such as synthetic minority oversampling (SMOTE), random subsampling, and rigorous model evaluation including cross-validation.